Dear reader,
Several of you emailed yesterday, asking me to write something on the matter of Chay Bowes, who has just been sanctioned by the European Union on account of – in the EU’s telling – being essentially a Russian agent of influence.
There are, I think, two separate and distinct issues at play here, and we should address them separately and in turn. The first is the question of whether Bowes is what the EU says he is. The second is whether it was within its rights to sanction him, and whether this is a good development or a bad one.
We’ll take them in turn.
Funny story: In the whole time that I was editor over at Gript, we were only sued three times. The first time was by Chay Bowes.
We’d run a story all the way back in 2020 (now for some reason paywalled), around about the time that Bowes was presenting himself alongside his great friend Paddy Cosgrave as a thorn in the side to Leo Varadkar in the “Leo the Leak” scandal (which ended up not being much of a scandal). That story revealed that Bowes, in addition to his public facing persona, was the author of an anonymous online pro-Russian account called “Questionitall71”.
Between 2011 and 2015, that account pumped out – anonymously – relentless Russian propaganda, some of it graphic, much of it false, and almost all of it in the cause of praising the eternal President of the Russian Federation, Mr. Putin. Bowes promptly sued us, though his precise reasons for doing so are lost to my memory. Something about describing some of the tweets as homophobic, I think, was part of it.
In any case, the case never went anywhere and he never got a penny out of it. Bowes decamped to Russia, got a job with Russia Today, the Russian state-funded broadcaster, and started saying openly and under his own name very similar things to what the Questionitall71 account had been saying previously.
Look, it’s a free world, and the man has made his choices.
What I can say about Bowes is that while he is being paid by the Russians today, I could find no evidence then or now that he was being paid by them from 2011-2015 when he was advocating aggressively for Russia while based in Ireland. Bowes, for whatever reason, has the hots for the Kremlin. And he seems to have found that ideal situation in life which we should all seek: Getting paid for something he loves doing and was previously happy to do entirely for free.
So yes, he’s a Russian shill. It shouldn’t be controversial to say so, and some who may have fainting fits at that description wouldn’t bat an eyelid if we described an RTE presenter as compromised by the funding he or she gets from the Irish state.
The second question is more subtle. Is the EU within its rights to sanction him as aggressively as it has? It’s now against EU law to, essentially, do any business with Bowes. You cannot send him money or pay him for services. To do so would be a crime.
These are severe sanctions, that essentially confine him – economically – to Russia. If he has remaining assets in Ireland, he may struggle to access them.
And he has, for the record, committed no crime of which I am aware, while remaining an Irish citizen.
Further, Europe is not, officially, at war with Russia. A distinction that, while technical, matters to my mind morally, if not legally (the EU has, indeed, the power to do what it did). Were Europe at war with Russia, then there would certainly be a statable case to indict Bowes as an EU citizen providing, in essence, aid and comfort to the enemy.
But formally, that is not the case. Nor has he been accused of espionage. The EU has instead accused him of taking part in Russian “disinformation operations” – though it has not disclosed the evidence for this charge, or formally accused him of any crimes.
He is, in essence, a European who has defected to Russia and broadcasts pro-Russian views with – charitably – a questionable factual basis.
That, to my mind, does not meet or come close to meeting the moral threshold for the action the EU has taken, despicable though I find those views.
There are two things that I think about all of this.
The first is that it displays a terrible lack of confidence, in Europe. Chay Bowes is one pro-Russian voice on the internet and not, to my mind at least, a very effective one.
We’re only talking about him at all because Europe itself has marked him out as a threat. And therefore, worth listening to. That is a mistake.
The second is that the precedent being set here is genuinely threatening. For what, exactly, is Bowes being sanctioned? Is it his views? Or is it being paid by Russia while living in Russia?
It is a very small step from sanctioning Bowes to sanctioning people with other views that the EU finds threatening. Indeed, it has already done this, sanctioning a German blogger, Thomas Roper, last year. Again, without formally disclosing any underlying evidence that Roper was not acting or speaking entirely on his own initiative.
Why not sanction crusty pacifists who preach against European re-armament but never seem to find a breath to criticise Moscow? (Is PANA, with its endlessly boring press releases, next?)
Mind you, while I do ultimately oppose what’s happened to him here, I’m not going to shed many tears on behalf of Chay Bowes. While there is no declared war underway between Russia and Europe, there can be no nationalism in Europe without defending the right of small states not to be bullied and controlled by their larger neighbours.
Bowes picked his side, many years ago. He is now fully immersed in it. He is, as close as it is possible to be without actually being one, an effective spokesperson for the Russian regime.
And, for all my problems with the EU, I remain a supporter of the western way of life and western freedoms as opposed to the Russian dictatorship and the casual way it throws away the lives of its young men to satisfy the imperial ambitions of an aging dictator.
We’re on different teams. But it is precisely because we are on different teams he should not have been sanctioned in the way he has. In the west, we tolerate dissent, even when dishonestly expressed. In Russia they do not.
That’s the difference we should be fighting to preserve. That’s what I think.
J.



Lord Haw Haw comes to mind.
Never heard of this guy until I read this. The man may very well be a deluded creep but has he broken any law ? .
It would seem that the European Union is reviving the medieval concept of the outlaw. Where undesirables were driven out of society by being declared to be outside the law and thus fair game to be murdered.
The EU is certainly not defending the rule of law. What's it's doing is defending itself and the clique that are running it, and in doing so it exposed it's own total disregard for the rule of law. They are dangerous people and will dispose of anyone who threatens their empire of lies