Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Henry Gaynor's avatar

It's the same with the criminal justice system. It's designed to never solve crime. If we could add something to our water that would magically make everyone a law abiding citizen there would be a whole cohort of people out of work .. Gardaí, prison officers, lawyers, barristers, judges, probation officers, etc. The justice system we have is designed to keep crime and everyone who benefits from it ticking along nicely.

Jack Harper's avatar

It’s the same in the mainland UK. People and politicians (are they people—if so a very strange version) have a naive inability or a wilful refusal to accept an economic axiom.

Outside of a full blown command economy the public sector produces absolutely nothing. Its mere survival is dependent on taxes paid by the private sector and its employees. The tax on the wages of public sector employees is just a refund of those wages, reducing the amount of the net subsidy from the public sector that the private sector must fund.

The capability of the private sector to provide that funding is not infinite, is sensitive to tax and regulatory burdens placed on it, and with the Laffa curve fully operational.

There is no magic money tree. Groceries and petrol are not mysteriously manufactured at the point of sale in unlimited quantities for those who can afford to buy. And the Public sector plays no part in their manufacture or provision.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?