16 Comments
User's avatar
Kelly's avatar

Thank you for this. You touched on a lot of what I've been saying here and on other social media, and as a woman, I'm taking quite a beating. I, like too many women, have my stories but I am not Jane Doe.

She didn't leave when she could have, didn't ask for help while texting her roomie at 3 a.m., chose repeatedly to take ketamine, didn't call it out as wrong until she felt snubbed and judged. Calling this “rape” is an insult to every victim who could not just walk out, or make a phone call mid-way, or who was stone cold sober minding their own business when they were forced into a situation they couldn't escape.

The behaviour of both Jane Doe and the frat boys is a damning indictment of a culture where Only Fans is sold as empowerment, and porn is ubiquitous casual viewing. Cornell's normalizing of group sex, free sex toys etc in various classes is also a problem.

But regret sex is not rape. And that's what it looks like right now.

Henry Gaynor's avatar

If all eight were intoxicated and high on drugs can any one of them be held accountable for their actions. There's a clear double standard at play in this consent debate .. a woman who is drunk cannot be expected to make responsible decisions yet a man who is drunk must act like he is sober. If a drunk woman has sex with a drunk man aren't both of them rapists?

Jackie's avatar

Agreed - feminists have demanded to be seen as equal to men, however they don't want to held accountable for making poor choices. Nobody comes out of this covered in glory, but regret sex in not rape (IMO). I remember yrs ago having this conversation with a male friend of mine - his contention, if you parked your much loved valuable car on the street you'd have a steering lock an alarm system and you'd lock the doors.. you'd protect it from opportunists and would be ner do wells. Feminism has destroyed the world for both men and women

Jacob's avatar

Unfortunately, the summary of the facts is not correct.

Jane Doe didn't meet Man 1 on a night out, she had been texting with him previously. He was at the frat house when she arrived.

While Man 3 was a friend of Man 2 (in the sense that they were frat brothers), Man 3 entered the room because it was his room.

Man 2, not Man 3, sent the "free p*ssy" snapchat.

There is no sex in the room after Men 4, 5, 6, 7 enter the room.

What you are referring to as one of the men saying they should stop is Man 3 (and another man, not one of the 7) who enter and say everything needs to be shut down.

Subsequent to that, Men 1 and 4 take Jane Doe to another room, where the third threesome of the night occurs.

It's not the case that she "denied consent for anything that happened", she says she did not consent to Man 7 kissing her when he entered the room.

Holm Braeuer's avatar

Making consent the basis of rape does make sense. Nobody wants sex they weren't willing to have in the first place. But consent can't really be established by anyone. It's inherently contextual. Even if you give it explicitly, you may later find that what you meant and expected wasn't what it turned out to be. Neither the supposed victim nor the supposed perpetrator has control over that. Which means there's a genuine problem here.

Uber Keats's avatar

I think you’re close but I think it’s more fundamental.

You’re right that everyone is saying, ‘Something has gone wrong here,’ but what’s gone wrong is that sexual immorality is a thing, and we don’t know how to process that anymore because the metric for sexual morality—not just what is and isn’t rape—is consent in the modern age, and by hearing about a 19-year-old girl enact porn In The Wild, we’ve realised that it’s not enough as a metric.

But we dare not speak of that because it might mean conceding that the Church had a handful of decent points for a few thousand years. The founding myth of modernity is that the Patriarchy is 100% awful, but this story scratches something in the back of our minds that monogamy and sexual restraint might actually be connected to human social order and human health and not a disgusting form of conservative control.

FFP's avatar

Saw a rape trial where it was regret. Jury rightly threw it out. It cost taxpayers and defendant a lot. False claimants should pay costs.

Andrew's avatar

By world standards, this is not an important story. Yet it has been picked up and misreported by progressive columnists in Ireland as a cause celebre for their 2010s politics.

Meanwhile, there are countless stories of similar magnitude around the world (the teenage rioters in France who attacked their female teacher, say) which the media don’t touch, presumably on the grounds that they are particular to their countries and not deserving of international attention. Well, the Cornell case proves that there is nothing small enough to report on if it can be used in the cause of our media’s progressive worldview.

Frank's avatar

Feminists have moved the goalposts on consent to the point that women can consent to sex at the time,then cry rape a year later,

The other aspect of this case is that the attorney general of New York has presumed Jane Doe ti be the "victim", without reading all the evidence. Despite this obvious bias, she may still be allowed to be the special prosecutor.

Frank's avatar

One of the men claims that she sexually assaulted him without his consent - she did oral sex on him when he was passed out. You didn't mention that sutuation.

Elaine Finnegan's avatar

In my view she was stupid to go back with that young man in the first place and those lads were equally just as stupid for taking part in it. My issue is with the lad who sent the text out. To me he is the guilty party because he knew the situation and made it worse. I don’t know what kind of outcome anyone expects from this.

burgercrisis's avatar

Lot of factual errors, assumptions outside the evidence, critical omissions, etc.

Debkin's avatar

In these cases you want to reserve judgment simply bc someone intoxicated could at any point pass out and it’s in those cases men often take advantage even though it’s gross. I’m not saying this happened here. But a conscious person who doesn’t say no it’s unclear to me how would a man know? I don’t like consent being removed w any intoxication bc the logical outcome there the only fair outcome is this would apply to men too. How would this help anyone arbitrate this? This is also battles of sexes stuff and a failure of feminism. You can claim all you want that cheap sex for men is the same as it is for women but on the whole it just isn’t. Look what took place here. It seems her sisters wanted her to restore her reputation by claiming non consent after “processing” that can surely happen but it directly conflicts things she said that were unambiguous. So unless there’s other evidence this does look like something immoral but not criminal. The immoral part for me is not necessarily the sex though I’d advise men not to engage with women they barely no who are intoxicated but the degrading comments disinviting her to the party which really seems to be what moved this all. If I were her sister I’d have her post an analysis of their performance bc it’s typically poor in these cases but as much as women profess they are men they aren’t. And having sex w someone you at least like as she indicated is going to feel a lot better than having it w people you don’t just to experiment. Men just want a place. This isn’t all men but it’s most men. Of course I have an impulse to protect female honor and don’t give too much thought to men’s sorry guys but I also am not going to bring my different standards into judgement of law over morals. Also can you guys in college lock a freaking door I mean seriously.