Dear reader,
I have a hunch that not many of you follow the ins-and-outs of Australian Cricket, so you are most likely unaware of the “Sandpapergate” scandal that is currently roiling our antipodean convict-descended friends.
A short precis: Eight years ago, during a match in South Africa, cameras spotted an Australian player, Cameron Bancroft, rubbing sandpaper on the ball to make it behave in a more bowler-friendly fashion. This being cheating, it provoked an enormous scandal at the time. Bancroft, along with then-Captain Steve Smith and opening Batsman David Warner, were all suspended from the team, taking full responsibility for the cheating and exonerating the other players. Bancroft, a young player at the time, barely ever played for Australia again. It ruined his career.
And that was a sad tale, fading into memory, until last week: Eight years on, Bancroft, and other players – sparked by an autobiography from a teammate - are now saying that they were not solely responsible at all. Everyone else in the team, including current captain Pat Cummins, knew full well what was going on, they now say.
It’s one of those rows that has taken sport from the back pages to the front. Cummins may well have to resign. And Australian cricket may be punished twice for the same mistake. Once convicts…. Always convicts.
Or in other words, as someone once said of Richard Nixon, it’s the cover-up that gets you in the end.
All of which, speaking of convicts and the man who once said “I am not a crook”, brings me neatly to Sinn Fein.
This week, as some of you may have heard, the party issued instructions to its TDs on how to answer a question most of us already know the answer to. What you say if someone asks you “what is a woman?”, they told their TDs, is that the answer is “adult human female”.
The cynics amongst you might notice an omission: Nowhere is the word “biological” used. And since the Irish gender recognition act lets virtually anybody assign themselves as “female” in law, we’re not technically any closer to an answer. But that will go over the heads of most voters.
(Image AI generated, if you didn’t get that somehow)
No, the problem for the Shinners is not the answer, per se. It is that coming up with an answer was necessary in the first place. And that the act of coming up with an answer is, in effect, a cover up of a sort.
Is there much difference between being on the one hand a party that does not know what a woman is, and on the other hand a party that requires a definition of womanhood to be delivered to their TDs, lest they be confused?
In the first instance, I am not sure there is.
In the second, I am not sure who they aim to please.
Sinn Fein, much like the Australian Cricket Team, is forever running away from what it used to be. It has spent much of the last two decades desperately trying to convince us all that it is no longer an organisation that uses violence to achieve its aims. Not everyone, of course, buys that. But it has mostly succeeded.
It then went through something of a change on its attitude to the EU. I have a fond memory of sitting in meetings with Mary Lou McDonald during the first Lisbon Referendum – she’s very nice in person – planning the “No” campaign. Sinn Fein was ever opposed to the EU. Until Brexit, when it realised that the EU might be a tool to convince wavering northerners about the badness of the border. Now, up north at least, it’s as pro-European as the late Jacques Delors, peace be upon him.
Now, it is embarked upon a third race: To try and convince everybody that it is no longer woke. They’ve changed. Again.
Let me tell you the trouble that the Australian Cricket Team have with Sandpapergate: In the late 1990s and early noughties, under the leadership of Steve Waugh, the Aussies garnered a reputation for ruthlessness. That they would do anything to win. They would bend the laws of the game, verbally abuse opponents, and engage in a strategy Waugh called “psychological disintegration” to defeat their opponents.
After that, you might understand why many people have a difficult time believing that the whole team wasn’t in on the cheating.
Sinn Fein has a similar problem. Ultimately, you cannot outrun what your record says that you are. This is a party ever changing, and ever evolving, and always coincidentally changing and evolving in the direction of wherever it thinks the voters are.
There’s a problem there, even if you welcome what it says on a given day: You cannot ever trust it. What it promises you today, it may abandon tomorrow.
Just ask the transgenders.
If you want to explain Sinn Fein’s doldrum-like meandering in the polls, down from the once heady heights of 34%, this is it almost entirely, I think. This is not a party offering a bold new direction for the country. This is a party always trying to pretend to be something it’s not.
The Shinners have one animating passion and one only: The border. Should that ever go (and I am not holding my breath) then who knows what they’ll become.
But in the meantime, I wouldn’t be much fooled by their pretence to suddenly know what a woman is.
J.




A photo of the Daily Mail front page headline about this popped up on my phone. I immediately thought that it was a joke front page. I never for one minute imagined that it would be necessary for a political party to tell it's members what a woman is. How wrong I was.
When David Cullinane spoke out, Sinn Fein had the opportunity to be a party that allowed diversity of opinion on this issue and accommodate a frank working-class attitude to gender woo. Mary-Lou didn't even have to endorse it, merely to tolerate it and thus for the party to better represent its notional base. But the old pull of authoritarianism and dogma were too strong.