Dear reader,
As all of the other news outlets you read will inform you, Riad Bouchaker was sentenced today to life in prison for the attempted murder of children on Parnell Square almost exactly three years ago.
Under the parole act of 2019, life in prison in Ireland means that you must serve at least a dozen years before you are eligible to be released on licence, though in fairness parole is not guaranteed. Bouchaker, hopefully, will never be a free man again.
Yet even at that, for my money he hasn’t really been punished in any meaningful sense. He’s been deprived of his liberty, certainly. But instead of being fed and watered and housed by the Irish taxpayer as a free man, he will now do so in confinement. And he’ll likely get better healthcare. There’s little about his life as reported in the courts that suggests he’s missing out on much by being locked up.
This is not, to be clear, the fault of Judge Tony Hunt, who dispensed the maximum sentence available to him under Irish law.
But why is that the maximum sentence? Why did we decide that this was more humane than hanging? And did we – I include myself in this – not get it horribly wrong?
For years, I’ve gone back and forth on the death penalty. In my 20s and 30s I was, instinctively, opposed. I would prefer not to believe that the state should have the power to take your life from you, since it was given to you by God or whatever other name you want to give that force greater than ourselves that makes us all unique and different. A life cannot be replaced, though almost everything else can. Case closed, or so I used to think.
But then there are cases like this one. Where it can objectively be said that Bouchaker’s life is not really worth preserving.
He is in his fifties now and has had five decades to demonstrate to us all that there is something worthwhile to his existence. In that time, he came here, claimed asylum, never worked a day in his life in Ireland, and felt so aggrieved by all of this that he tried to kill innocent children in what appears to have been an act of collective vengeance on the rest of us for his lot in life.
Hanging him would not be an act of bloody vengeance. It would be an act of self-defence. Not against him, necessarily: But by establishing the price of a child’s life and innocence. In this case, execution would not devalue life but increase its value.
That’s one of the things you hear people saying, isn’t it? “There’s no value put on life any more”.
Well, that sort of starts at the top. If the penalty for trying to kill a child – in this case multiple children – is just a standard life sentence, then that implicitly sets society’s value on a human life. And it sets it low.
If the penalty is execution, it sets the value on life higher.
Our progressive friends will say, and they will be right, that the death penalty is not much of a deterrent. And they are right because in most cases, a murderer doesn’t expect to get caught. Few people commit murders expecting to go to prison or face the consequences.
And that’s why deterrence is the wrong conversation entirely.
The death penalty, properly applied, is not about stopping future crimes, though if it does that might be considered a bonus.
It is about the rest of us, as a society, deciding what the value of our own lives is.
One of Riad Bouchaker’s victims will never have a normal life. We may only pray that her recovery surpasses all present expectation.
So for the rest of us the question is: what value do we place on that loss? How do we as a country and a people react to it, when there is no doubt whatever about the reason for it or the person behind it?
For my money, the only acceptable answer to that question is that Bouchaker should lose his own life. Not brutally. Not performatively. But in a matter of fact way.
We would not be executing him because we hate him, though I am sure some of us do. We would not be executing him as vengeance, though vengeance would be justified. And we would not be executing him merely as punishment, though the punishment would be deserved.
No, we would be executing him because, in the simplest terms, that would be the price of what he did. The price of speeding is three penalty points and a fine. The price of trying to kill a child is death.
That is how you set the value of human life to its appropriate level.
It is the only sentence that is just.
I recognise that in writing this I may alienate some of my catholic readers, just as I would probably alienate my 30-year-old self. But mercy, sometimes, is not the same thing as justice. And it is the latter with which the state should be primarily preoccupied.
That is an argument we should not be afraid to make.
J.



Well said. And after he is executed deport his body to Algeria.
Putting a human being to death is a terrible thing for a society to do, but more terrible still is accepting the stabbing of children as the price for keeping our hands clean. Some crimes are so terrible that the ordinary protections offered to transgressors are a mockery of justice.