18 Comments
User's avatar
Karl Martin's avatar

Well said. And after he is executed deport his body to Algeria.

Donal Moloney's avatar

Putting a human being to death is a terrible thing for a society to do, but more terrible still is accepting the stabbing of children as the price for keeping our hands clean. Some crimes are so terrible that the ordinary protections offered to transgressors are a mockery of justice.

Henry Gaynor's avatar

I don't think it's that terrible for a society to kill people. We train soldiers to kill people in our defence. We also train specialist Gardaí to take out dangerous criminals if it's deemed necessary. We also do abortion and plans are in train to bring in euthanasia.

Ben Meehan's avatar

Personally, I do not believe the state should have the power to execute its own citizens (particularly, this state, can you imagine the incompetence)? However, I simply do not understand why we cannot seem to adapt the UK model of life, but with a recommendation to serve a minimum of X number of years (possible 40 in this case) before parole may be considered. This seems like common sense to me. I'd love to hear a good argument against it.

Henry Gaynor's avatar

It's much cheaper to terminate someone than it is to keep them in prison for forty years. It costs around €100,000 per year to keep a prisoner in jail in Ireland .. that's a million Euro for a ten year sentence. Termination is too dangerous for a first conviction as there is always the risk the conviction might be declared unsafe at a later date. But by conviction number three criminals have used up their unsafe conviction pass and their opportunity to go straight pass. There is no point in being nice to nasty people .. it simply doesn't work. To my knowledge, Riad Bouchaker has no previous convictions which would mean I wouldn't be in favour of terminating him but your point in this regard should be examined. There are examples of prisoners serving longer than mandatory life in Irish prisons but I'm not sure what criteria applied to them .. serial killers Shaw and Evans being an example.

Henry Gaynor's avatar

We definitely should have the death sentence for serial offenders .. I would argue they should be humanely terminated on their third conviction. What is the point in giving people who don't give a damn about others endless opportunities to generate more crime victims. By making it the third conviction allowances are being made for a possible wrongful conviction and for the convicted person to learn from their "mistake" and never offend again.

__browsing's avatar

Serial offenders in what sense? Multiple homicides, or just violent offences more generally?

Henry Gaynor's avatar

The termination of serial offenders should apply to all kinds of offences. There is no such thing as a victimless crime. Every time we let a criminal commit another crime we are creating another victim. Instead of looking at leniency as giving a criminal another chance to rectify their behaviour we should see it as giving them another opportunity to prey on another victim. Being nice to bad people doesn't work.

__browsing's avatar

...I dunno, man. I can see the argument for sentencing getting harsher with multiple convictions, but I wouldn't send a guy to the chair for three accounts of shoplifting.

Henry Gaynor's avatar

Why not shoplifting? If you owned a shop, shoplifters are robbing you of income. If you pass the losses on to your customers, shoplifters are robbing them via higher prices. Why should victims of shoplifting have to suffer from serial shoplifters? The obvious solution is to take shoplifters out of circulation for good, and the cheapest obvious solution is termination. Putting them in jail means their victims must pay taxes to fund imprisonment. Buying a pistol is a one off investment in justice .. the only additional expense is bullets which I'm sure most crime victims will gladly pay for. Termination is a no brainer .. let the criminals worry about the morality of it .. the rest of us should just go and enjoy life.

Gordon Kingston's avatar

I'd worry not so much about his death, but of what we'd expect, in sangfroid, of the executioner (I know, many people wouldn't have a problem with doing it). Maybe a full life sentence in solitary confinement? Though that’s not allowed here.

James Gough's avatar

The refined effete liberal sensitivities of the west can't withstand close contact with the raw savagery of Islam. The rulers of the Islamic world know this and would have dealt with this worthless piece of failed humanity according. But then again had this attack happen in a Muslim land there would have been no gaggle of women surrounding and protecting him and he would have been despatched on the spot

Jessie's avatar

I went on a tour to Wicklow Fail, a very interesting place. The Tour Guide spoke of the various types of torture inflicted on prisoners including children even for the crime of stealing a loaf of bread. With the introduction of various rights for prisoners their time in prison is a walk in the park compared to previous times.

Gerry Claffey's avatar

Argument well put

Sean's avatar

I think the argument against the death penalty in his case is incredibly weak & basically amounts to people selfishly putting their own conscience up against the public good.